Deep dive into the philosophy of enlightenment in Advaita Vedanta, drawing from the manual *Vedanta Sara* (“The Essence of Vedanta”). Talk
– The central question posed is: **Can consciousness (Atman or Brahman) be known by the mind?** The Upanishads present contradictory views:
a) Some say **the mind cannot reveal consciousness** because consciousness is not an object to be known. b) Others suggest **only the mind can realize consciousness**
This contradiction leads to the key inquiry: **What is the role of the mind in enlightenment?**
Enlightenment is defined here as **knowing what consciousness is, or self-knowledge**. The discussion emphasizes understanding what “knowledge” means in Vedanta, especially **how self-knowledge differs from ordinary knowledge**.
…………………………
– **Pure consciousness** is described as **Sat-Chit-Ananda** (Existence-Consciousness-Bliss) or **bare awareness**, independent of brain or mind.
– Consciousness is **not an object but the illuminator of all objects**.
– Vedanta presents three models of how consciousness is experienced:
– **Reflected (Pratibimba)**
– **Channeled (Abhasawada)**
– **Limited (Nacada)**
– Awareness is first experienced in the **mind**, where the reflection of pure consciousness appears.
– The mind **reflects or limits pure consciousness**, then channels it to the body and senses.
– Consciousness in the mind illuminates all mental activities (thinking, feeling, desiring, ego, intellect).
– The **reflection in the mind is called “reflected consciousness”** — analogous to a face reflected in a mirror.
– This reflected consciousness is **not the real consciousness but a facsimile**.
– The path to enlightenment involves moving **from the reflected consciousness in the mind back to the real pure consciousness itself**.
– **Every conscious experience has two components:**
1. **Mental modification (Chitta Vritti)**: the mental content or thought (e.g., “1 + 1 = 2”)
2. **Reflected consciousness**: the awareness illuminating that mental content
– Example: Seeing flowers involves light entering the eyes → signals to brain → mental modification in mind (“flowers”) → reflected consciousness illumines it → experience arises.- This framework applies to all experiences: thinking, imagining, working, suffering, etc.
– The Sanskrit terms explained:
– **Vitapa**: pervasion or presence of mental modification.
– **Phalabi**: pervasion or presence of reflected consciousness.
– Knowledge/experience = **vitapa (mental modification) + phalabi (reflected consciousness)**
– Ignorance arises because: – Consciousness is everywhere but without mental modification of an object, it remains unknown.
– Example: Not seeing behind you because no mental modification is present about that object.- This is the **Vedantic epistemology of ordinary knowledge**.
– In ordinary knowledge:
– Object = external things (flowers, book, etc.)
– Instrument = senses and mind
– Experience = mental modification + reflected consciousness
– In **enlightenment (self-realization)**:
– Object = consciousness itself (Atman/Brahman)
– The question: **How can consciousness know itself?** The analogy of **moon and sun** is introduced to explain this: The **moon reflects sunlight to illuminate the earth at night**.
– Similarly, **pure consciousness (sunlight) is reflected by the mind (moon) to illuminate the world (earth)**. The mind focuses (pervades) on the world, and reflected consciousness illumines what the mind focuses on.
– Key points in this analogy:
– The **mind’s pervasion (focus) corresponds to the moon’s phases**; the reflected consciousness is like moonlight. Just as a flashlight illuminates a dark room only where it points, the mind must focus on something to reveal it through reflected consciousness.
The **solar eclipse as an analogy for self-realization**:
– During a **solar eclipse, the moon comes between the Earth and the Sun, blocking the sun’s light from reaching the Earth**.The light from the sun is reflected back toward the sun by the moon, **not illuminating the Earth**. This represents the **mind turning inward**, away from the external world, like the moon blocking the sun’s light.
– Key insights from this analogy: The **sun (pure consciousness) is always self-illuminated**, requiring no external reflection. The **moon (mind) cannot illuminate the sun**; it only reflects the sun’s light toward the Earth. When the mind turns inward (solar eclipse), it stops reflecting consciousness outward and instead realizes the **self-illumination of consciousness**.
– Vedanta teaches:
– **Pervasion by mental modification (mind’s focus) is necessary for enlightenment.**
– **Pervasion by reflected consciousness is not necessary for self-realization.**
– The mind must be completely oriented inwardly towards **Atman/Brahman** through meditation, devotion, self-inquiry.
– This explains the apparent contradiction in the Upanishads:
– “By the mind it cannot be known” → because reflected consciousness (phala-bi) is not necessary.
– “By the mind it can be known” → because mental modification (vitapa) is necessary.
– The path of spiritual practice is likened to **the solar eclipse**, where worldly distractions fade into darkness, allowing the **sun (consciousness) to realize itself**.
– **Consciousness (Atman/Brahman) is self-illuminating and cannot be fully known as an object by the mind**.
– **Ordinary knowledge arises from the interplay of mental modifications and reflected consciousness in the mind**.
– **Enlightenment occurs when the mind turns inward, ceasing to reflect consciousness outward and instead recognizing pure consciousness as itself**.
– The **solar eclipse analogy powerfully illustrates this inward turn** and the distinction between ordinary knowledge and self-knowledge.
– The **mind’s focused attention (mental modification) is essential for enlightenment, but the reflected consciousness in the mind is not**
– This dual role of the mind explains the contradictory Upanishadic statements on whether consciousness can be known by the mind.
– Spiritual practice aims to create the mental focus (vitapa) on Brahman, enabling self-realization.
– The teaching clarifies that **you do not become conscious by the mind; consciousness is already present and self-revealing**.