Vedānta operates only as śabda‑pramāṇa, revealing the ātman by systematically negating adhyāsa through precise methods such as adhyāropa–apavāda, anvaya–vyatireka, and lakṣaṇā. Without understanding this methodology, śravaṇam remains intellectual; with it, the pramāṇa functions and the vision becomes immediate.
Pramana Vichara
Swami Dayanandaji’s book on Pramana Vichara is a great book on understanding how humans understand knowledge. We can look at as a methodology (Pedagogical ) steps that one needs to understand and then the Shastra terminology steps.
Every pursuit of knowledge begins by asking: How do I know what I know? Swami Dayananda frames this enquiry as essential because Vedānta is not a belief system — it is a means of knowledge. Before approaching the Upaniṣads, the student must understand: Every pursuit of knowledge begins by asking: How do I know what I know? This sets the stage for a disciplined, non‑mystical approach to self‑knowledge. The Pramana vichara book walks the student through the basic pramāṇas available to every human being: Each is illustrated with simple, relatable examples. Swami Dayananda emphasizes that: This prepares the student to appreciate why ātma‑jñāna requires a different pramāṇa altogether. The text then establishes the central thesis: Vedānta is an independent means of knowledge (svatantra‑pramāṇa) for the nature of the self. It reveals: These are not available through perception or inference. A major pedagogical contribution of the book is explaining how words can reveal the self. Swami Dayananda shows that: The emphasis is on method, not mysticism. A pramāṇa is validated by the knowledge it produces. Vedānta is a pramāṇa because it consistently resolves confusion about the self and produces stable, doubt‑free knowledge. Throughout the book, Swami Dayananda: The student is guided to see that mokṣa is a cognitive shift, not an experiential event. In Summary This pedagogical version highlights the book’s core teaching: To understand the self, one must first understand how knowledge works.
– What counts as valid knowledge
– How a pramāṇa operates
– Why Vedānta requires a unique pramāṇa
This sets the stage for a disciplined, non‑mystical approach to self‑knowledge
Swami Dayananda frames this enquiry as essential because Vedānta is not a belief system — it is a means of knowledge.
Before approaching the Upaniṣads, the student must understand:
The pedagogical aim is to show that every pramāṇa reveals a specific domain, and no pramāṇa can trespass into another’s territory.
Thus, the Upaniṣads are not philosophy — they are revelation in the sense of a pramāṇa, not dogma.
The book clarifies:
Vedānta is not a philosophy to be believed but a pramāṇa to be understood.
Pramāṇa‑vicāra is the foundational enquiry that precedes all Vedānta. Before the śāstra can operate as a means of knowledge, the student must discern the nature, scope, and necessity of a pramāṇa. Swami Dayananda establishes this enquiry with uncompromising clarity.
- Pramāṇa-Svarūpa
A pramāṇa is that which produces pramā—valid, doubt‑free knowledge—by revealing what is otherwise unknowable.
Each pramāṇa has a specific domain (viṣaya), a specific operation (vyāpāra), and a specific result (phala).
No pramāṇa can trespass into the domain of another.
- Bādhita‑anadhigata‑viṣaya
For knowledge to be valid, it must be:
- Anadhigata — not knowable by any other means
- Abādhita — not sublated by any other means
This criterion becomes central in establishing Vedānta as an independent pramāṇa.
- The Limitation of Laukika‑pramāṇas
Perception, inference, and postulation operate only within the empirical field (vyavahāra).
They cannot reveal:
- The non‑objectifiable self
- The identity of jīva and Brahman
- Dharma and adharma
- The nature of Īśvara
Thus, the empirical pramāṇas are paricchinna—limited by their very structure.
- Śabda as a Svatantra‑pramāṇa
The Veda is presented as svataḥ‑pramāṇa, an independent means of knowledge.
Its authority does not rest on logic, perception, or mystical experience.
It reveals what cannot be known otherwise—ātma‑svarūpa and brahma‑satyatā.
- The Operation of Vedānta
The Upaniṣadic sentences (mahāvākyas) function through:
- Adhyāropa‑apavāda — deliberate superimposition and negation
- Anvaya‑vyatireka — co‑presence and co‑absence analysis
- Lakṣaṇā — secondary implication where direct meaning fails
Through these methods, the śāstra reveals the ever‑present, self‑evident ātman.
- Pramā vs. Bhramā
The enquiry distinguishes:
- Pramā — knowledge that aligns with reality
- Bhramā — error born of ignorance and projection
Vedānta is a pramāṇa because it consistently resolves bhramā regarding the self and produces stable, non‑negatable knowledge (akhaṇḍākāra‑vṛtti).
- Adhikāritva
The śāstra’s operation depends on the preparedness of the student.
A mind endowed with śraddhā, viveka, and samādhāna becomes a fit instrument for the pramāṇa to operate.
- The Central Vision
The enquiry culminates in the recognition that:
- The self is ever‑evident
- Ignorance alone veils this fact
- The śāstra, handled by a competent guru, removes this ignorance
- Mokṣa is not an event but the resolution of error
Thus, pramāṇa‑vicāra is not peripheral—it is the very gateway to Vedānta.
Various Strategies used in Vedas to Reveal the Unexplainable
The Vedas use a variety of strategies to reveal something which cannot be revealed directly by simple language but with the hope that we intuitively will understand what is being pointed to, the intended meaning of the words (“Tatparya”). This is very important to discover as our minds are falsely conditioned by mundane worldly experiences and activities.
Neti Neti (not this not this)
if you cannot directly say what it IS, you can you can say what it is NOT. So nirguna Brahman can be expressed by neti neti (not doer, enjoyer etc)
Adhyaropa Apavada
use adhyaropa apavada superimposition and removal of qualities and attributes (e.g. all pervading Ishvara, limited Jiva “attributes/qualities” etc).
Paradoxical Language
use paradoxical language to describe something beyond normal language a) greater than the greatest (e.g. space-like), b) smaller than the smallest (space like) c) further than the furthest d) nearer than the move nearest e) it moves but it moves not (all pervading space like) f) independent of space-time etc. and with the hope that we will understand what the paradox points towards. Words can only take us to the edge of knowledge.
Lakshana
Intuitive understanding (lakshya artha) of the implied meaning of the words is the way to understand the equality of Brahman Consciousness and Atma Consciousness. It is the same non-dual Consciousness.
The differences will continue to “appear” to us in the transactional reality, but intuitively we understand that there is only one underlying reality, Consciousness. So just BE in that understanding.
Unique approaches by Upanishads to reveal Ultimate Truth
Despite their different methods to reveal the Ultimate Truth, all the major Upanishads share common emphasis on Advaita (unity of Brahman and Atman), and importance of Self-Realization. Essence of Important Upanisads-Audios Despite their different methods to reveal the Ultimate Truth, all the major Upanishads share some common themes: By using diverse methods like dialogues, stories, analogies, and direct statements, the Upanishads provide various pathways for seekers to understand and experience the ultimate Truth. The Taittiriya Upanishad is an enlightening text composed of three sections known as Vallis (chapters): the Siksha Valli, Ananda Valli, and Bhrigu Valli. These sections together provide profound insights into the nature of Brahman (the ultimate reality) and the path to realizing it. Here’s how the Taittiriya Upanishad reveals Brahman: Siksha Valli Ananda Valli Bhrigu Valli By guiding through ethical conduct, meditative practices, and the analogy of the five sheaths, the Taittiriya Upanishad bridges the gap between individual experience and universal truth, helping practitioners realize the pure consciousness that is Brahman The Mandukya Upanishad, one of the shortest but most profound Upanishads, uses a unique and systematic method to reveal the ultimate Truth, which is the non-dual nature of reality (Advaita). Here’s a breakdown of its key approaches: In summary, the Mandukya Upanishad uses a unique method to reveal the Truth by: Through these methods, the Upanishad guides the seeker to realize the true nature of the Self as identical to Brahman, transcending all limitations and duality. The Mundaka Upanishad, like other Upanishads, aims to reveal the ultimate Truth, which is the oneness of Atman (the individual Self) and Brahman (the ultimate reality). However, it employs a distinct method to achieve this. Here’s a breakdown: In summary, the Mundaka Upanishad reveals the Truth by: Through these methods, the Upanishad guides the seeker towards the realization of the oneness of Atman and Brahman, leading to liberation from the cycle of birth and death. The Ishavasya Upanishad, with its concise 18 verses, employs a unique and direct method to reveal the Truth, which is the all-pervading nature of the Self (Atman) and its oneness with Brahman. Here’s a breakdown of the key aspects of its method: In summary, the Ishavasya Upanishad reveals the Truth by: Through this unique approach, the Ishavasya Upanishad provides a powerful and direct path to understanding the nature of reality and achieving liberation. The Kena Upanishad is a profound text that explores the nature of Brahman (the ultimate reality) through a unique inquiry-based approach. Its structure revolves around a series of questions and answers that delve into the deeper aspects of consciousness and the nature of the self. Here’s how it reveals Brahman: Chapters I & II: The Inquiring Mind Chapter III: The Nature of Brahman Chapter IV: The Epilogue Key Concepts: The Kena Upanishad uses poetic and philosophical dialogues to reveal the profound truths about Brahman, guiding seekers towards a deeper understanding of their own true nature and the ultimate reality. The Katha Upanishad is a rich and profound spiritual text that unveils the nature of Brahman through a series of dialogues between Nachiketa, a young seeker, and Yama, the Lord of Death. Here’s how it beautifully reveals Brahman: Dialogue and Inquiry Key Teachings About Brahman Metaphors and Parables The Path to Realization Two Paths By using metaphors, ethical teachings, and deep philosophical dialogue, the Katha Upanishad provides a profound exploration of Brahman’s nature and guides seekers on the path to understanding the ultimate reality. The Prashna Upanishad reveals the concept of Brahman through a structured method of six profound questions posed by seekers to their guru, Pippalada. Each question delves into different aspects of cosmology, life, and meditation, gradually unveiling the supreme truth of Brahman. Overview of the Six Questions: Key Concepts: The Aitareya Upanishad is another significant text in the corpus of Upanishads, originating from the Rigveda. It presents an insightful view of Brahman (the ultimate reality) through a cosmogonic narrative and deep philosophical discourse. Here’s how it reveals Brahman: Creation Narrative Human Beings and Brahman The Concept of Atman (Self) Higher Knowledge (Para Vidya) Identifying Brahman The Aitareya Upanishad reveals Brahman through the narrative of creation, the nature of the self, and the means of attaining higher knowledge. It guides seekers to understand that their true self is not separate from the ultimate reality, leading to a profound realization of oneness with Brahman. The Chandogya Upanishad is one of the principal Upanishads, part of the Samaveda, and is key in Vedantic philosophy. It explores the nature of Brahman (the ultimate reality or universal spirit) through a variety of dialogues and teachings, some of which illustrate the following points: These teachings aim to guide individuals towards the realization of Brahman, transcending the material world and recognizing the unity of the self with the ultimate reality. The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, one of the oldest and most significant Upanishads, delves deeply into the nature of Brahman (the ultimate, unchanging reality) through intricate discussions and teachings. Here are some key ways in which it reveals Brahman: By addressing the nature of existence, consciousness, and ultimate reality, the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad guides individuals towards the knowledge of Brahman – the eternal, infinite truth.Prashna Upanishad
1. Source of Creation:
2. Prana and Its Functions:
Aitareya Upanishad
Spiritual Journey – Acronyms and Terms by Swami Paramarthananda
The spiritual journey of self discovery can be quite challenging as the human mind can be deceptive. It helps to keep focus by remembering (and memorizing) these helpful acronyms.
B– Bandakatvam – Bondage
A– Atrupthikaratvam – Dis-satisfaction, unfulfillment.
D– Duka Mistutatvam – gives sorrow)/ pleasantness
Karma Yoga = Proper action + Proper attitude
R– Reduce adharmic activities
I– Increase dharmic activities
D– Dedicate all actions to the Lord
E– Experience everything as Prasada
Deva Yagna – worship of Devas
Bhuta Yagna – worship of Environment
Manushya Yagna – Humanity
Brahma Yagna – worship of Ishvara/Brahma Intelligence
Pitru Yagna – worship of Ancestors
Self esteem
Serenity
Setup harmony
Spiritual growth
Frequency of emotional disturbances – reduces
Intensity of emotional disturbances – reduces
Recovery period – gets shorter
Calmness
Cheerfulness
Confidence
All increase
FEar of disease
DEpression due to inability to do things
REgret over the past
Loneliness
Possessions
Obligations or responsibilities
Relationships
Transactions
Jnana Yoga Preparation II = CLASP Rejection or Renunciation
CLaim of ownership and controllership
Anxiety
SPecial prayers seeking special favours for special people
Jnana Yoga = Path of Wisdom
Consistent and systematic study of vedantic scriptures for a length of time from a
competent live Guru.
Receive and assimilate through Shravanam, Mananam and Nididhyasanam
JNANA YOGA
FIVE CAPSULES OF VEDANTA
1. I am of the nature of eternal and all pervasive consciousness
2. I am the only source of permanent peace, security and happiness
3. By my mere presence, I give life to the material body and through the body, I experience the material universe
4. I am not affected by anything that takes place in the material world and in the material body
5. By forgetting my nature, I convert life into struggle and by remembering my nature, I convert life into a sport or entertainment
Five Features of Consciousness / ATMA / I
1. Consciousness is not part, product or property of the body
2. Consciousness is an independent entity or principle which pervades and enlivens the body
3. Consciousness is not limited by the boundaries of the body
4. Consciousness continues to exist or survive even after the death of the body
5. The surviving consciousness is not accessible because of the absence of the body medium
FORMAT CONVERSION
A karma yogi has a world view which can be presented in a triangular format of Jiva,
Jagat and Isvara
A jnana yogi has a world view which can be presented in a binary format of atma and anatma
A karma yogi becomes a jnana yogi by format conversion to binary format
CONTEMPLATION
All the pains and pleasures belong to the material body and world, the anatma. I am the atma or consciousness. I am nitya muktaha.
Brahma Satyam. Jagat Mithya. Aham Brahma Eva Naparaha.
More Explanations
The nature of the Creation
1) It is multifarious, has no-substance, is transitory, and not real (Aneka, Asara, Anitya, Asatyam – Jagat mithya,
2) Everything is Ishwara in different Name and Forms (NF) only.
3) Jagat is effect/karyam, and useful for transactions in NF. Holding on/relying on effect is
Samsara with all its problems.
4) Discover the cause/karana (Brahman) of the creation to be free.
5) Dependence on world, leads to Samsara life which becomes MBBS leading to HAFD. MBBS –
Meaningless, Burdensome, Boring, Struggle. HAFD – Helplessness, Anger, Fear, Depression .
1) Dependence on world, leads to Samsara life which becomes MBBS leading to HAFD.
MBBS – Meaningless, Burdensome, Boring, Struggle. HAFD – Helplessness, Anger, Fear, Depression .
because “events” in the world are constantly changing and not in our control. So “depending” on the world leads to dukkha/dukkha/sukkha.
Objects of world have features of OMACT – Objectifiable, Material (panch maha bhuta), Attributable, Changing, Temporary/Transitory (drsyatvam, bhautikatvam, sagunatvam, savikartvam, agamapayitvam)
God is essence of the world. ESNS – Eka (one), Sara (substratum), Nitya (timeless), Satyam (truth)
Karma Yoga path for life – Proper Actions + Proper Attitude. RIDE R- Reducing Adharmic
Activities, I – Increasing Dharmic Activities, D – Dedicating all actions to Ishwara. E –
Experiencing everything as Prasada
Benefits of Karma Yoga are the 4Ss – increasing Self Esteem, Serenity (Samatvam), Setup Harmony
(Pancha Maha Yagyas – Environmental care) and Spiritual Growth.
– With Sadhana chatushtaya Sampatti, one reduces FIR and increase CCC. FIR – Frequency
of emotional disturbance, Intensity of disturbance, Recovery Period. CCC – Calmness,
Cheerfulness and self Confidence
Sadhana Chatushtaya Sampatti or the fourfold means for salvation (four kinds of spiritual
practices), is a pre-requisite to the aspirant in the path of Jnana Yoga (Vedanta). The four means
are:
1) Viveka -discrimination between Sat (real) and Asat (unreal).
2) Vairagya -dispassion or indifference to sensual enjoyments herein and hereafter.
3) Shad Sampat (6 virtues):
a. Sama -peace of mind through eradication of desires, cravings and subtle Vasanas.
b. Dama -control of sense organs.
c. Uparati -satiety, renunciation of all activities not enjoined by scriptures (Sannyasa).
Mind engaged in Sravana, Manana and Nidhidyasana
d. Titiksha – endurance, forbearance, without complaints or giving up.
e. Sraddha -faith in scriptures and the Guru’s words.
f. Samadhana -concentration of mind, balance of mind, equanimity to opposites.
4) Mumukshutva -Intense longing for liberation.
To be free of bondage of samsara, it is necessary to have internal sannyasa (vairagya – dispassion)
and move towards PORT reduction, and CLASP rejection.
PORT – Possessions, Obligations, Responsibilities, Transactions.
CLASP – CL -ControLlership/ownership (aham-mama abhimana), A – Anxiety, SP – Special Prayers (sakama prarthana)
6 recognized pramanas are the means of gaining knowledge for humans:
1) Pratyaksha (Direct Perception),
2) Anumana (Inference after),
3) Upamana (Comparison),
4) Arthapatti (Postulation, presumption),
5) Anupalabdhi (knowledge of non-existence), and
6) Sabda (Verbal Testimony). University education etc. but also could be Shastra.
– Due to Ignorance, Delusion, Projection, Reaction the normal behavior of a samsari is that of Jivaatma (a person who believes himself to be a limited person), separate from others and Jagat.
Upon vedanta based enquiry: Body Mind (BM) is also experienced like other objects of jagat and is
OMACT. -i.e. achetana. It borrows sentiency from Consciousness – C which is chetana. It is the
divine principle behind all organs. Eye of eye etc. It is the subject / witness / sakshi of the objects. 5
principles of Consciousness, C
1) C is Not Part, Product, property of body
2) C is independent principle, which pervades and enlivens the body
3) C is not limited by Body Mind (BM)
4) C continues to exist beyond BM
5) C continues to exist in seed /potential state but not available for transactions without manifestation in a being. (even a single cell Microbe, exhibits sentiency)
Message of Vedanta is in 5 capsules
1) I am of the nature of the eternal and all-pervading C
2) I am the only source of permanent peace security and happiness
3) By my mere presence, I lend existence to the material BM complex; and through the material BM, I experience the world.
4) I am never affected by any event that happens either in the material world; or, in the
material BM complex.
5) By forgetting my real nature, I convert life into a burden (HAFD). Once I know this, then Life
is a blessing; because, it is an opportunity to claim my higher glory. Life is celebration ha vu ha vu ha vu.
Brahman manifests as Sat Chit Anantam in living beings, and as Sat in non-living beings. Thus
Brahman pervades all of creation.
Saguna Ishwara ritual devotion (God as separate) should be converted to Nirguna Brahma understanding!.
– Consciousness / Self is only understandable thru Vedanta based Sabda pramana as taught thru guru parampara. It teaches about claiming the Sat Chit Ananda – Atma as ones swarupa. Conversely,
applying the neti neti principle, and using conventional pramana methods one needs to discard
everything (anatma) that is experienceable. That is the Push/push method in Upanishads.
– With dedicated Sravanam, (study) , Mananam (to remove all doubts), and Nidhidyasanum ( to
internalize the knowledge) the enquiry leads to freedom, jivan muktaha.
– Karma Yoga + Jnana Yoga = Bhakti Yoga (appreciation of the god’s grace)
– Karma Yoga mindset transformation into Jnana Yoga mindset is necessary
FORMAT CONVERSION
Akarma yogi has a world view which can be presented in a triangular format of Jiva, Jagat and Isvara
A Jnana yogi has a world view which can be presented in a binary format of atma and anatma
A karma yogi becomes a Jnana yogi by conversion from triangular to binary format.
For a Jnana Yogi, Moksha is freedom by claiming that I am Nitya Muktaha (Brahman) -Soham,
Bramhasmi.
CONTEMPLATION
All the pains and pleasures belong to the material body and world, the anatma. I am the atma or
consciousness. I am nitya muktaha.
Brahma Satyam. Jagat Mithya. Aham Brahma Eva Naparaha.
Enquiry into the Intended meaning of Tattvamasi
All Vedanta texts culminate in the final teaching of the mahavakya Tat Tvam Asi (That Thou Art) or Aham Brahma Asmi (I am Brahman). The relationship between That and Thou has to be analyzed through 3 steps:
Samanya adhikaranam
Are all the words in the sentence referring to the same thing or do they refer to different things. Since we are discussing non-dual reality and that You are Brahman, then ultimately we are talking about one reality. The words all point to the same reality, same locus (adhikaranam). E.g. blue lotus, the word lotus and the word blue both refer to that same flower.
Visheshana Vishesha Bhava
Is the meaning of the words a noun- adjective relationship, substance (Lotus) and quality (blue). Or is it noun to noun? Ishvara (God) and Jiva (You) are one (connection to infinity). This noun (infinite Ishvara) to noun (limited Jiva) as a direct meaning excludes other names and forms, that Ishvara (not Vishnu, shiva etc) are Jiva (you or me). However, such direct meaning also has glaring contradictory qualities and are equitable (Ishvara are omniscient etc and Jiva as limited). Therefore, we need a 3rd step of investigating the implied meanings.
Lakshya (pointed/implied) lakshana (pointer/defn) bhava:
What is the Tatpariya/intended and Implied meaning of That and This after discarding any “qualities” superimposed on them. Eg. that devadatta (young one from different city) is this (elderly, coming towards me). Any contradictory qualities (include space-time effected) are discarded and the intended meaning “person” is understood. Eg. That blue lotus (month ago in the pond) is this blue lotus (aged and in a pot). or Ganga river implies the same river whether it was a trickle in the Himalayas or flooding at the mouth in bangladesh.
So now analyzing the sentence Tat Tvam Asi. Tat is implying to Nirguna Brahman, pure consciousness without the upadhi of universe created by maya. Tvam – Nirguna Atma – Self Consciousness without the upadhi of body-mind-senses. Asi – The Consciousness substram is non-dual, one without a second, the same. The sentence is before the universe was manifested it was one existence without a second.
However, Nirguna brahman is beyond language of words. So a word (written on spoken) has a direct meaning (through pratyaksha pramana through vachya artha), it must refer to something within this manifested union with this universe ( created by maya), it could be the cause of the universe Ishvara, because cause and effect are manifestations in the same order of reality. The range of a language can only indicate manifested cause and effects and therefore it can only directly denote Ishvara, as saguna Brahman. However Ishvara (all pervading, etc) and Jiva (limited, insecure) can never be equated. So there has to be deeper meaning to the words.
Jiva-Brahman connections and suggested Sadhana
The connection between Jiva and Brahman is mystery that everyone needs to explore. Vedanta rishis came up with 3 models thousands of years ago. That of Avaccheda vada, Pratibimba vada, and Abhasa vada, to describe the apparent manifestation Brahman into Jiva of various of types and various states of ignorance. Some additional emphasis of certain sadhana may be given in addition to the normal Sravanam, Mananam, and Nididhyasam. The subject is also relevant today, as AI robots developments and innovations are trying to mimic consciousness and compare that with humanity. Details are in this document. Jiva-Brahman Models and Sadhana to be free explained
